I am new to soaping. I did make some alterations to the Wal_Mart recipe with some coco butter, some meadowfoam, and some clay. But it's in a boring scent, Vanilla Cream. Some people who've smelled it didn't think it was vanilla because it's a musky vanilla. They wanted a light vanilla I guess. I love the way this soap feels. I have done lemon verbena with citrus peel (my best seller....gone) My favorite is my Honey Oatmeal (boring) but it sure makes my dry itchy skin feel good.